Tuesday , 21 May 2024

Noonan: Comments On Developing Market Activity For Gold & Silver (+2K Views)

…[ignore] those pundits who are saying PMs are ready to take off…  How has that been working out?  If you applycrowne-gold-silver-bullion_l a little bit of common sense, and you look at these charts, can you draw any other conclusion(s)? Always remember: the markets never lie and here is what they are saying.

The above introductory comments are edited excerpts from an article* by Michael Noonan (edgetraderplus.com) entitled Gold And Silver – For Now, Charts Proving More Reliable Than Fundamentals.

The following article is presented courtesy of Lorimer Wilson, editor of www.munKNEE.com (Your Key to Making Money!), and has been edited, abridged and/or reformatted (some sub-titles and bold/italics emphases) for the sake of clarity and brevity to ensure a fast and easy read. This paragraph must be included in any article re-posting to avoid copyright infringement.

Click on Facebook for latest articles on gold/silver & economic/financial matters from munKNEE.com

Click on Twitter for latest tweets from munKNEE.com

Click here to subscribe to the FREE Market Intelligence Report newsletter (sample here)

Noonan goes on to say in further edited excerpts:

For those whose eyes glaze over at the prospects of reading a chart, it is in your best interest to view them from a common sense perspective.  For those who have read our articles for any length of time, you know we place primary consideration on looking
at developing market activity, as best seen in a chart.

The Importance of Understanding Developing Market Activity

What is developing market activity?  When the collective of all decision-makers, from the most informed to the least informed, from the well-heeled to those barely getting by, and everyone in between makes a decision to buy or sell in any market, that decision is then recorded as to price and volume, to reflect the numbers of decisions made at any given price level on any given day.  The results of these decisions is what creates a high, low, and closing price for any selected time period.  This is what creates a chart.

What is important to understand is that the collective decision-making process takes in those with the most access to information, those professionals who have the best and most reliable facts and data in their research capabilities.  This smaller collective is what moves any market directionally.  It is what creates a trend.

In addition to the above, there are a myriad of other participants:

  • those who look at news and events, those who consider fundamentals,
  • those who employ conventional technical tools,
  • those who think they can outguess the market, pick tops and bottoms,
  • those who are short term traders, long-term traders, day traders, and
  • those who may use any combination of everything available,

all with a single objective:  Placing their bet and hoping to win. Smart money does not rely on hope.  They have specific rules for engagement, and if those rules are not met, they do not engage.

Developing market activity is the way in which to read what all of the best minds and those with the best capitalization behind them are doing.  They will not tell you what they are doing, but you can “see” what they are doing once they make a decision to buy or sell in the market.  You can “see” where/when they bought/sold and at what price, (volume).  All one need to is follow the (visible) trail left behind by reading price and volume.

Once you begin to (appreciate and) understand that these observations are “messages” from the market, as a result of smart money decision-makers, you are now looking at the most current and most reliable information available for anyone and everyone to “see!” Sometimes, the best place to hide something is under the brightest light.  People do not pay attention to it.  Who would believe the best available information to be right under their nose, (eyes)?

The above is basic but extremely important to grasp in order to understand the important information that can be gleaned from a chart.  Almost all of the known fundamentals for gold and silver say the price for both should be higher.  How much higher is subjective, but the fact that both should be priced higher, for inflation-adjustment alone, says higher.  Yet, we all know gold and silver remain at recent lows.  This tells you there are other influences at work.  There are these seemingly exogenous forces that remain unseen that are impacting the market.

What the Charts Are Saying


…When you look at the chart of annual activity, the decline from the 2011 highs, while relatively large, looks like a correction in an up market, and it is.  When you take a look at the quarterly, with more detail, the current lows are still well above the last swing high, at the beginning of that chart.  This would be an example of bullish spacing on this larger, and more controlling time frame.

What is bullish spacing?  It occurs when the last swing low, just under 1200 on the Qtrly chart, stays above the last swing high, just above 1,000 at the beginning.  This says that buyers are willing to buy, (and support), prices without waiting to see a retest of the last swing high.  Here you have an important piece of market information, a message from the market, that buyers are willing to buy in without waiting, a bullish indication in the overall pricing scheme.

Why is this important to know on these rarely looked at, (by the public), larger time frames?  Because larger time frames are more controlling over smaller time frames, and it takes more time and effort to change the pattern of a larger time frame.

Where do the bulk of traders spend their time?  Looking at daily and intra day charts, the smallest time frames and easiest to change.  These time frames also are where most people lose money in their decision-making…

Despite people’s views on gold and silver being in a down trend, from a larger perspective, both are in up trends, and that is what the overall news is saying and what everyone senses: gold and silver should be higher.  Well, they are.  It just depends on your frame of reference.  From a larger time frame, gold and silver are working higher.  The problem is people are looking through the wrong prism and making the wrong decisions, as a consequence.

Most of the activity of the last several quarters has been near the lower end of the wide range bar down, 4th bar from the end.  Even though the broader picture is bullish, the current last few quarters are under 50% of the range of the 4th bar, and even lower when
using the range from the all-time high to the recent low.  Conclusion?  Price has not demonstrated an ability to rally back higher, yet.  We see that more clearly on the lower time frames.

Gold – Monthly Chart

The monthly chart below shows the price in a down trend, and most recently, trading sideways. Again, the market is sending a message, if you care enough to heed it.  The market, which we have defined as the collective of all decision-makers, is saying, regardless of what you read in the news, regardless of your belief that gold and silver should be higher, for whatever reason, valid or not, the message from participants is: it ain’t ready to go higher, at this point.

GC A, Q, M 5 Jul 14

Ignore the message at your own peril.  Forget about those pundits who are saying both PMs are ready to take off, and they draw a huge arrow point higher.  How has that been working out?  If you apply a little bit of common sense, and you look at these charts, can you draw any other conclusion(s)? Always remember:  Markets never lie.

Gold – Weekly Chart

The weekly chart below provides an example of the opposite of the bullish spacing discussed above: bearish spacing.  It is when the most current swing rally high fails to reach the last swing low, creating a gap between them.  Here, bears are confident enough that the trend will stay down that they do not need to wait and see how the last swing low will be retested before selling.  It is a message from the market to expect lower prices. You can also expect future resistance when price does eventually rally to that level.  These are pieces of the market puzzle that fall into place when you let the market tell you what to expect moving forward.  This also presents a conflict between the higher time frames and the lower ones.  The lower ones are used more for timing.  If you are trying to time a long position, the market is telling you to wait, for paper futures.

GC W 5 Jul 14

Comments on the charts…suggest there is a lack of clarity for continuation higher next week, or not.  This is why we state a note of caution should be observed.  The short-term momentum is up, granted, but within downward pressure that is still apparent, so one has to respect this cautious tone.

Gold – Daily Chart

Getting into finer details of the market’s information, what is important to observe is HOW price responds at resistance.  So far, it has not backed away like it did in mid-April and near the end of May.  What this rally has going for it is the Demand overcoming Supply (D/S) bar, a wide range rally and strong close on very high volume, (effort). We could be seeing a change of behavior where buyers are taking control from sellers [but] this cannot be known for certain until confirming evidence shows up.

GC D 5 Jul 14

It is possible that last Thursday’s wide range bar may contain price activity over the next several Trading Days [TDs].  If so, buyers could be absorbing the efforts of sellers in preparation to go higher.

  • If price sells off the week of July 6th, how it sells off will matter. 
    • If the ranges are small and volume is lower, that will indicate a lessening of selling and buyers can step back in and take price higher and break overhead resistance.
    • If a sell-off occurs on wider ranges down and increased volume, buyers near last week’s rally will be trapped, depending on how low, if at all, price declines.

There could be a high volume washout to the downside, similar to Thursday, or that may have been a washout.  We cannot know for certain until the market confirms the behavior just described.  You always want to wait for the market to confirm its most recent action before taking new action.


Silver is showing similar characteristics to gold, as just described.  So far, on the annual chart, the response for 2014 has been weak, relative to the decline of 2013, but anything can happen in the next 6 months.  What is known for certain is that silver is struggling, and possibly basing on the higher time frames.

Silver – Monthly Chart

The monthly chart below is more in concert with the quarterly, in that regard.  There are still layers of overhead resistance and bearish spacing.  Regardless of what one’s outlook is for silver, current developing market activity is sending a message that price is nowhere near ready to rally. That can change next week or next month or sometime thereafter… [but] what can be determined with a high degree of certainty is what the chart message says “right now.”

SI A, Q, M 5 Jul 14

Amplifying the chart comments above, the small ranges of the last two weeks make this a not so clear read.  The small ranges say buyers could not extend each weekly range higher, yet the closes are both in the upper half of each week’s range, and that says buyers were more in control than sellers.  Because the overall trend is down, near term, the onus is on buyers to prove change, and that appears lacking here, or at least questionable.  This is why the note of caution is given. Price can continue higher next week, or decline, with no argument.  That makes for very low probability odds, either way, and reason enough to not participate until odds improve.

It can sometimes be difficult to divorce one’s hopes, opinions, or anticipations from expectations, but if one wants to make money instead of being “right,” one has to go with the information known and deal with what is. 

Silver – Daily Chart

If anyone missed the recent rally, and we certainly did, you can see that there will be many opportunities ahead because of all the resistance waiting at higher price levels.

SI D 5 Jul 14


Do not be distracted by the “noise,” (news/events).  Let the market be your guide.

Editor’s Note: The author’s views and conclusions in the above article are unaltered and no personal comments have been included to maintain the integrity of the original post. Furthermore, the views, conclusions and any recommendations offered in this article are not to be construed as an endorsement of such by the editor.


Related Articles:

1. Noonan: These Charts Say Trend STILL Bearish For Both Gold & Silver

No one knows when gold and silver will rally and anyone who says otherwise has already been proven wrong. Despite a decent rally in both gold and silver over the past 7 trading days, a look at the charts shows that both remain in bear market conditions overall with no defined indication of ongoing strength. Read More »

2. Noonan: Everything’s Upside Down, Including the Price For Gold & Silver – Here’s Why

We live in an Alice In Wonderland, circa Orwell’s 1984 world. Everything is upside down, and that includes the price for gold and silver. Read More »

3. More Conclusive Evidence Needed Before Jumping On the Latest Gold Bull Story – Here’s Why

The short-term outlook for gold is promising. However, with the golds having moved so far so fast, they are a little extended here. I would like to wait for more conclusive evidence of upside breakouts before jumping on the gold bull story. Let me explain why I hold that view Read More »

4. Is Gold Ready To Bounce? Not Likely! Here’s Why

Gold and silver have been all over the map in 2014. To figure out what’s next for the metals this article assesses their deep and long term status as speculative assets and the relationship between the two metals and determines what must happen to reverse their continuing decline. Read on! Read More »

5. The Pain Is Probably Not Over For Silver Bulls! Here’s Why

Silver has now dropped to $19 and is down 3.1% for the year. Unfortunately, the pain is probably not over – yet. Read More »

6. Noonan: How Long Will These Low Prices In Gold & Silver Continue?

How long these low prices in gold and silver will continue is the ever pressing question on the minds of the gold and silver community and topic of so many articles written by the experts. While many have striven to provide an answer, and 2013 failed to match the “predictions” as to the “When?” issue, the best answer is: For as long as it takes. Here’s why. Read More »

7. Noonan: Gold Remains Low For These Compelling Reasons

The current unnatural control over the natural forces of Supply/Demand could continue much longer than most expect – the disappointing expectations for 2013 may repeat in 2014. Here is how we see the developing “story” that explains why gold and silver have not changed trend. Read More »

8. Noonan: Forget About $5,000+ Gold; It Ain’t Goin’ Happen Any Time Soon!

Tell us where in the charts below there are any indications that the “true” value for gold should be in the $5,000 – $10,000 per troy ounce range, or silver in the $100 – $300 range. If you see extraordinary bullish signs within them, let us know, because we certainly keep looking and cannot find any needle in these “haystack” charts! Read More »

9. Noonan: The “Rothschild System” & the Present and Future Price of Gold

If the East has gained control of the gold, and the West is essentially insolvent to its core, why aren’t gold and silver finding a higher level that, at a minimum, would reflect a simple adjustment for inflation for the past few decades? The answer is really quite simple: the “Rothschild formula” is is alive and well. Let me explain just what the Rothschild formula is and how it is influencing the price of gold. Read More »


  1. Thanks for sharing your info. I truly appreciate your
    efforts and I will be waiting for your next write ups
    thanks once again.

  2. this is the best article on the chart and how to read it, thank you mr. Noonan Lisa

  3. I read Michael Noonan’s articles when they are posted here, as I suspect many other so, but that said, should one or more BAD international events occur then all bets are off.