Wednesday , 22 May 2024

Why I’m Not That Big On Gold

When you’re talking to a gold bug it is much like arguing with a priest about religion but to my gold bug friends here, again, is why I’m not that big on gold. Words: 725

In further edited excerpts from his original article* Steve Christ ( goes on to say:

Being heavily ‘invested’ in gold has always represented something of an Armageddon trade to me because in order for you to really profit from it in the long term, things would have to fall apart and stay that way.

In that regard, I don’t know that I’ll ever be that pessimistic about the future — even though I understand the dangers of debt, the printing presses, and a devalued dollar. In fact, I’ve written about all of them.

What’s more, I’ve always wondered how the gold bugs planned to cash in on their big payday when it finally arrived. Personally, I would rather own 50 lb. bags of beans and rice.

I also never understood anyone who ever said that gold was a “can’t lose investment” because somehow it’s “real money,” not a fiat currency. You see, fiat is a word that the gold crowd loves to sprinkle on top of every argument, as if the dollars in my pocket are as illegitimate as crooked third-world dictator. Just because it sounds scary doesn’t make it so.

The truth is gold as an investment is as fraught with risk as any share of stock, bond, or piece of real estate. You can and will lose money on the shiny metal if you buy the highs and hold on to it. It’s just that simple.

If you doubt this fact, just ask anyone who bought gold at the peaks in last gold craze. Thirty years later, the price would have to reach around $2100 today for that person to break even on an inflation adjusted basis … and that’s not including the carrying costs. Keep in mind, gold is a static investment that produces no cash flow.

Here’s the real reason I prefer stocks to physical gold: stocks offer investors, a piece of a pie that grows, not one that will always remain the same size.

That’s the key difference for me — and why I would rather invest in a company with a bright future and dividend than a shiny piece of metal that might be the currency of the Apocalypse.

Now can stocks lose value? Of course they can…but I have 5,000 of them to choose from and if I do my homework, I’ll find more winners than losers over time — my portfolio proves this.

On top of that, I can spread my risk across several different sectors, limiting the downside in markets that aren’t correlated. This is the real point in writing this article. When I want to sell, the market is always liquid enough for me to make an exit — something that is much more difficult to do with “hard assets.”

I suppose if I were a gold guy … if I had to choose … I would rather own the miners than physical gold itself but, that being said, I do think gold can go higher here without question.

In the longer term … say the next 10 years … who knows but as I said earlier, gold really isn’t my thing and I wouldn’t go all-in on it. Nevertheless, this is a trade that bears keeping an eye on and if, and when, it develops, I would be more inclined to go long GDX — the Market Vectors Gold Miners ETF — or an individual miner.

Editor’s Note: The author’s views and conclusions in the above article are unaltered and no personal comments have been included to maintain the integrity of the original post. Furthermore, the views, conclusions and any recommendations offered in this article are not to be construed as an endorsement of such by the editor.


If you liked this article then “Follow the munKNEE” & get each new post via

Related Articles:

1. Gold Is A Risky Investment – Here’s Why

If I am right about my views going forward then gold isn’t just risky based on past performance, but it could be even riskier in the future as the “faith put” subsides and the myth that “gold is money” disappears. Read More »

2. I Don’t Mean to Rant Against Gold BUT

I don’t mean to rant against gold. I just think that there are some fundamental reasons to keep gold in the proper perspective when we consider its value as a portion of our asset holdings. In my view, it’s not the type of asset you want to build a portfolio around. Here’s why. Read More »

3. Careful! Gold’s Performance in Times of Crisis Often Not As Expected

We can devise logical scenarios as to what the price of gold should or should not do, but gold doesn’t always follow the plan. To paraphrase an old Jewish saying: “Man plans. Gold laughs.” Read More »

4. Gold is NOT a Perfect Inflation Hedge! Here’s Why

Almost any traditional inflation hedge [such as gold, silver as well as real estate, stocks or whatever,] has difficulty in reaching the break-even point on an after-inflation and after-tax basis when we take into account the pervasive problem of hidden “inflation taxes”…If our future is one of high inflation, then whether and how you deal with inflation taxes may be one of the biggest determinants of your personal standard of living for decades to come… Why? Because government fiscal policy destroys the value of our dollars and government tax policy does not recognize what government fiscal policy does, and this blindness to inflation means that attempts to keep up with inflation generate very real and whopping tax payments, on what is from an economic perspective, imaginary income. [Let me illustrate that fact with three examples and suggest some remedial measures.] Words: 3085 Read More »

5. 10 Myths That Suggest Gold Supposedly Has a Bright Future

…Hype, fear and outdated monetary theories simply aren’t enough to support the price of gold. Every finance and economics text book teaches that gold is basically an inflation hedge, and without inflation gold is simply a useless piece of yellow metal. Either the gold bugs are right or the Fed is right, and my money is on the Fed. Read More »

6. Where Do Gold & Silver Rank in Vulnerability to a Recession Among Other Commodities?

A Barclays Capital research [report] notes that gold prices are vulnerable to a recession – more so than some of the other commodities. In the last recession of 2008, gold prices appreciated the least among precious metals. Below is a table that ranks 30 different commodities. Words: 571

One comment

  1. ridiculous article.Clueless