Wednesday , 21 February 2024

Canada Continues to Avoid Humiliating Welfare State Experiments of U.S. & Europe

Register to “Follow the munKNEE and automatically receive all articles posted

Across Europe and the United States, millions go without work. Those who do work face a lifetime of crippling taxation to pay for the entitlements of their countrymen and the debts of their governments. Canada by contrast is strong. To stay that way, we must never repeat the mistakes of Europe and the United States and we must instead focus on what Canada has already done right. Words: 1320

So said Mr. Pierre Poilievre, Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Transport, Infrastructure and Communities and for the Federal Economic Development Agency for Southern Ontario, CPC, (  in his opening comments in a speech in the Canadian House of Commons (Parliment) last April to defend economic freedom and to warn his colleagues of a fiscal cliff that many economies like the U.S. and European Union were headed to. It can be seen here or read in its entirety below:

This article is presented compliments of (A site for sore eyes and inquisitive minds) and (Your Key to Making Money!) and may have been edited ([ ]), abridged (…) and/or reformatted (some sub-titles and bold/italics emphases) for the sake of clarity and brevity to ensure a fast and easy read. Please note that this paragraph must be included in any article re-posting to avoid copyright infringement.

What went wrong in the United States?

Many believe that the 2008 financial collapse and recession were the result of irresponsible behaviour by business and banks. In fact, this behaviour was merely the symptom. The illness was massive government intervention to turn the mortgage business into a social program.

The roots of this go back three decades. Presidents from Carter to Bush Jr. wanted to expand home ownership, a worthy mission no doubt. To do this, they mandated government-sponsored enterprises like Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae to cover the risks of loans to people who would otherwise not qualify for them. We call these subprime mortgages.

According to a World Bank report, Freddie and Fannie, both government sponsored enterprises, bought an estimated 47% of these toxic mortgages. Harvard financial historian Niall Ferguson estimated that between 1980 and 2007 the amount of government backed mortgages increased from $200 million to $4 trillion. Furthermore, the American government not only encouraged but forced banks to provide these loans.

To quote the World Bank report, “In the mid-1990s, the government changed the way the Community Reinvestment Act was enforced and effectively compelled banks to initiate risky mortgages”.

Once Americans are in debt, the U.S. government encourages them to stay there by allowing them to write off their mortgage interest. The bigger the mortgage debt, the lower the taxes.

In sum, the government encouraged millions of Americans to spend money they did not have on homes they could not afford, using loans they could never repay and then gave them a tax incentive never to repay it. The state had pumped so much air into the mortgage bubble that it burst. Financial institutions collapsed, taxpayers were on the hook, millions were jobless and one in five American households went under water, and that is to say their mortgages were bigger than the value of their homes.

To make matters worse, those same American households have trillions of dollars in debt of which they are likely not even aware – government debt. The U.S. government debt is now bigger than the entire American economy. This is household debt, as families will need to repay it on their tax bills with interest, now or later. According to the U.S. Treasury Department website, mainland China holds $1.1 trillion of it.

To quote Mark Steyn:

“If the People’s Republic carries on buying American debt at the rate it has in recent times, then within a few years U.S. interest payments on that debt will be covering the entire cost of the Chinese armed forces.”

Imagine, through debt interest, soon American taxpayers will be funding 100% of the Chinese military.

Steyn points out, according to the congressional budget office, that by 2020 the United States government will be spending more annually on debt interest than the total combined military budgets of China, Britain, France, Russia, Japan, Germany, Saudi Arabia, India, Italy, South Korea, Brazil, Canada, Australia, Spain, Turkey and Israel.

[The Result of Europe’s Experiment With the Welfare State]…

The European welfare state borrows on taxes to give people stuff they have not earned. Recently, for example, Greek public sector workers took to the streets to demand the government continue to pay them 14 monthly paycheques per year. We call this socialism. Margaret Thatcher pointed out that the problem with socialism is that eventually you run out of other people’s money. We call that a “sovereign debt crisis”.

Standard and Poor’s has now downgraded French and Austrian government debt and further has reduced the ratings of seven other countries in the Euro currency block. Portuguese and Greek debts have now been downgraded to junk status by all rating agencies.

To avoid bankruptcy, the Greek government needs to borrow more. Because no one will lend its own money to that country, the European Central Bank must step up and lend 150 billion euros of other people’s money. Thank goodness, the EU has a bailout fund to prevent government defaults. Too bad Standard and Poor’s has downgraded that bailout fund. Soon the bailout fund will need a bailout.

What the Welfare State Leads To

I describe this humiliating American and European experiment with the welfare state because…we know where it leads.

  • Through government spending, the indulgence of one is the burden of another.
  • Through government borrowing, the excess of one generation becomes the yoke of the next.
  • Through international bailout, one nation’s extravagance becomes another’s debt.
  • Everyone takes and nobody makes.
  • Work does not pay and indulgence does not cost.
  • Money is free and money is worthless.
  • The system punishes work,
  • [the system] rewards sloth,
  • [the system] taxes the makers to pay off the takers and, quoting Thomas Jefferson,
  • [the system] steals “from the mouth of labor the bread it has earned”.

To paraphrase Rudyard Kipling: “In the era of generous government we were promised abundance for all, by robbing selected Peter to pay for collective Paul; but, though we had plenty of money, there was nothing our money could buy, and reality stood up and told us: if you don’t work you will die.”

[The Canadian Way]

Amazingly, opposition members ignore this timeless truth. They see the Europeans and Americans running off the debt cliff and say, “Let’s hurry and catch up”. No thank you, Mr. Speaker. I choose the Canadian way.

Canada is one of the greatest success stories of human history precisely because our leaders were practical and smart. From the beginning, they understood the basic rules of success:

  • people should work hard,
  • pay their bills,
  • spend only what they have and
  • let free people do the rest.

When Prime Minister Laurier declared that the 20th century would belong to our country, he said, “Canada shall be the star towards which all men who love progress and freedom shall come”. More freedom meant less government.

  • From 1900 to 1920, federal, provincial and municipal government spending was a combined 9% of Canada’s GDP.
  • Today, it is 39%.

Low-cost government meant a low-tax nation.

To quote the authors of The Canadian Century, Crowley, Clemens and Veldhuis: Laurier believed that the cost of government, and especially the tax burden, needed always to be kept below the level in the United States, so as to create a powerful competitive advantage for Canada [and] then, as now, Canada’s low-tax worked. In the first 20 years of the 20th century our population grew by an unprecedented two-thirds, the wheat yields in the Prairies by 500% and exports more than doubled.

Today we have an economic action plan based on our history. It tears down the walls of paperwork and protectionism:

  • so businesses and workers can reach the cornucopia of natural resources,
  • so we can reach foreign markets to create jobs and
  • so our entrepreneurs can build a mountain of success rather than drowning in a sea of paper …
  • welcomes skilled immigrants in and
  • punts fraudulent ones out.

We are in rough seas in the world today, yet we have a solid captain [Prime Minister Stephen Harper] and the bright star of our ancestors to guide him through stormy waters.”

Editor’s Note: The author’s views and conclusions are unaltered and no personal comments have been included to maintain the integrity of the original article. Furthermore, the views, conclusions and any recommendations offered in this article are not to be construed as an endorsement of such by the editor.


Register HERE for Your Daily Intelligence Report Newsletter

The “best of the best” financial, economic and investment articles
An “edited excerpts” format to provide brevity & clarity for a fast & easy read
Don’t waste time searching for informative articles. We do it for you!
Register HERE and automatically receive every article posted
“Follow Us” on twitter & “Like Us” on Facebook

Related Articles:

1. New Consumer Earnings & Spending Data Show U.S. & E.U. Citizens Living Way Beyond Their Means


The west is living far beyond its means and is struggling with pitifully anemic growth. This is a long-term trend, and one that is only going to accelerate. Nevertheless, as obvious as the indicators may be, few people will actually do anything about it. A lifetime of propaganda will plant many heads in the sand, ignoring the dangers and opportunities all around. [Let’s take a close look at just what these indicators are.] Words: 311

2. Canada Could Be Developing a Minsky Moment In Real Estate – Here’s Why


According to the Case-Shiller 10-City index Canadian house prices only appreciated by 84% between 1990 and 2006 compared to 181% in the U.S.. However, as U.S. prices plunged by almost 33% between the peak in April 2006 and the trough in May 2009, the chart below shows that Canadian home prices continued to rise, driven by very low interest rates and relatively benign unemployment. By July 2012, they had reached similar heights as U.S. prices before their decline and fall. I believe that house prices and consumer debt levels are overextended in Canada and that a “Minsky-moment” may be developing in Canadian credit markets. [Let me explain why I have come to that conclusion.] Words: 1892

3. How Much Higher Can the Canadian “Loonie” Soar Before Its Economy Gets Singed?


Booms — and the boom in Canadian commodities is no exception — are seldom without their unintended costs….[As the Canadian dollar appreciates versus the U.S. dollar, and with the U.S. as] its largest trading partner, falling Canadian exports could well induce a secular decline in the Canadian manufacturing base. Indeed, as the loonie soars, the inevitable question is: “How much higher before its economy gets singed?” Words: 528

 4. World’s Most Prosperous Countries: Where Do the U.S., Canada and Others Rank?


The Legatum Prosperity Index survey, as shown in the following table, ranks countries on eight different attributes, and then consolidates those attributes into an ‘overall ranking’. The report says that the U.S. has fallen out of the top 10 (to #12) in the ‘most prosperous country ranking’ increasing doubts about the health of its economy and ability of its politicians. Read the balance of the article to see where your country is ranked overall and in each of the 8 different categories. Words: 520

5. 18 Countries Now Have More Economic Freedom Than U.S. – Here are the Details


This year’s Economic Freedom of the World Index, which lists countries by most to least free using every available objective criterion, contains a real shocker when it comes to the United States. We aren’t just slipping on the index, we’re falling off a cliff. In many parts of the world, life is freer than in the “land of the free.” What this reports says about the United States should be front-page news. Instead, it has received barely any attention at all. The U.S. has fallen from a high of 2nd to its current 19th. Here’s why. Words: 1040

6. Uncle Sam vs. Johnny Canuck: One is Thriving, the Other is Just Surviving


For the first time in recent history, the average Canadian is richer than the average American. According to data from Environics Analytics WealthScapes published in the Globe and Mail, the net worth of the average Canadian household in 2011 was $363,202, while the average American household’s net worth was $319,970. [In addition,] Canada’s unemployment rate…[has fallen to] 7.2%, and America’s [remains at] 8.2%. Canada continues to thrive while the U.S. struggles to find its way out of an intractable economic crisis and a political sine curve of hope and despair. Words: 805

7. U.S. Dollar Ranks #4 Behind Currencies of Australia, Canada and New Zealand Among G10 Countries Based on Monetary Policy – Here’s Why


Merk Investments has ranked the attractiveness of the currencies of each G10 country based on the monetary and fiscal policies of each country and the strength of each country’s economy to come up with what they call the Merk Currency Score™. This Score should prove invaluable in supporting investment decision-making across countries and regions. Go here to see where your country ranks. Words: 367

8. Debt-to-GDP Ratio of 10 Largest Economies


Canada has the lowest total debt-to-GDP ratio of the world’s 10 largest economies (Australia is 2nd best, Germany 3rd and the U.S 4th) while the U.K. and Japan are 9th and 10th but when such debt is broken down by sectors the findings are quite different. Let’s take a look. Words: 800

9. Ian Campbell’s Commentary: Canada’s Many Economic Advantages Make it #1 – Here’s Why


Canada’s size, political structure, and culture will enable it to – properly governed – be more resilient to world economic problems than any other developed country. [For one thing] we don’t have the extent of political polarization that… [is currently the case] in Washington…and now exacerbated to new levels in these difficult economic times – and that will, in my view, cause the U.S. to continue down an increasingly rocky economic road. [Below I put forth Canada’s economic advantages and disadvantages.] Words: 1026

10. IMF to Consider Classifying the Canadian & Australian Dollar As Reserve Currencies


The International Monetary Fund said today that it is considering classifying Canada’s dollar, nicknamed the loonie for the image of a loon on the C$1 coin, and Australia’s dollar, as reserve currencies. Words: 285

11. Canada’s Oil Sands to Have $520 Billion Impact on U.S. Economy: Here Are the Facts, State by State


Canada is the largest supplier of oil to the U.S. When the U.S. imports oil from Canada, the spin-off economic benefits are substantial. The interactive map of the U.S. below will let you calculate the economic impact generated in each U.S. state from new oil sands projects in Alberta, Canada. Words: 592

12. A Look at the Canadian Oil Sands: the U.S.’s #1 Source of Supply

oil sands

The third largest source of oil in the world is the Canadian oil sands and the United States already imports more of it from there than from anywhere else. With oil prices on the rise, the controversial oil sands are likely to become even more economically viable, despite experts’ warnings about environmental risks [and the political and environmental gamesmanship to block the Keystone pipeline project from there to refining facilities in the U.S.]. Below are 12 incredible facts about the oil sands. Words: 408

13. Canada’s Top Commodity Exports/Imports & How to Invest Accordingly


Canada has the 7th largest economy in the world and is the 2nd largest country by land mass. It has a wealth of natural resources, making it a large energy and minerals exporter. For commodity traders looking to invest primarily in North America, Canada presents a compelling opportunity. [This article takes a look at Canada’s top commodity exports and imports and offers suggestions as how to invest in Canada’s commodity industry.] Words: 905

14. Canadian Oil Sands: World’s Single Largest Petroleum Resource and…


The Canadian oil sands are the world’s single largest petroleum resource at 1.7 trillion barrels. With conventional oil supply decreasing, heavy oil projects such as the oil sands become more attractive economically to meet the needs of growing demand. While environmental concerns about the oil sands remain, the options for plentiful, cost efficient, and clean oil sources are limited.

15. Still NO Housing Bubble in Canada – So What Will Cause Prices to Finally Correct?


Canada’s housing prices continue to escalate [there has been no housing collapse as there has been in the U.S., Spain, U.K., Australia and elsewhere over the past 4-6 years] but concern is rising as to whether they are now, finally, ‘in a bubble’ and about to correct either modestly or severely. This article discusses what would cause a change in direction in Canadian housing prices. Words: 500

16. Will Canada Soon See a 20-30% Correction in House Prices?


Canadians are becoming increasingly vulnerable to a housing correction, exposing them to a perfect storm of high debt and falling assets, the Bank of Canada warns…suggesting that many Canadians have constructed their finances on a house of cards, with ever rising home values the key and vulnerable support. [Sound familiar?] Words: 770

17. Housing Collapse Coming to Canada? House Price-to-Rent Ratios vs. America’s At Peak Suggest So


The ownership premium in Canada’s largest cities is unprecedented, dangerous to new buyers, and unlikely to persist – and if analogies to the U.S. situation at its peak back in 2005 are at all valid, this is bad news. [Let me explain.] Words: 430

18. American/Canadian Home Price Performance Comparisons by Major Cities


The following charts indicate relative performance of US home prices in Phoenix, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Chicago, Las Vegas, New York and Miami to Canadian home prices in Vancouver, Calgary, Toronto, and Montreal. US home prices are reflected in Canadian dollars for comparison purposes. Words: 240

19. Unlike the U.S and U.K, Canada’s Home Prices Are STILL Rising!


Canada, France and Switzerland stood alone among nine markets measured in recording annual price gains, based on second-quarter data, with inflation-adjusted price increases of 5%, 5% and 4%, respectively, compared to declines of 6% in the U.S., the U.K. and Australia, 10% in Spain and 14% in Ireland. In fact, Canada’s home prices have escalated 44% since 2005 – with a high of 68% in Vancouver – and they are up 7.7% in the past 12 months! Words: 1244


One comment

  1. Canada has abundant land mass and natural resources, yet it is mostly sparely populated, except in its major cities. Canada is now changing rapidly as the Political “will” to sell off resources is changing how the Government interacts with its people! Think how much control the Ultra Wealthy now have as compared to say only 10 or 20 years ago… As wealth gets concentrated in a ruling minority quality of life for the masses plummets!

    A great example from “South of the Border” is how the USA has changed in the last 20 years while its wealth has been “taken” from the middle class by one Gov’t. debacle after another which has only benefited the Ultra Wealthy, as if by design…