Tuesday , 5 March 2024

Noonan on Gold & Silver: Confirmation Required Before We Can Say “The Bottom Is In”

There is a potential for gold to be forming a bottom, based on the explanation provided171686-gold-silver-bars on the chart below, but there are a few steps that must be met before anyone can say, “The bottom is in.”  If these simple but important steps are not met, then there is the likelihood that yet another low can occur.

The above introductory comments are edited excerpts from an article* by Michael Noonan (edgetraderplus.com) entitled Gold And Silver – Wall Street, aka United States, Pulls Off Another Destructive Coup.

Noonan goes on to say in further edited excerpts:

Gold just took a turn for the positive, at least for now, when last week’s rally went above the broken support of the 1180 area and held…[That being said,] unless a bottom has been confirmed, and none has since the highs of a few years ago, then we get to deal with what is.  Unlike Clinton who said, “It
depends on what the definition of ‘is’ is,” our definition is confirmation.

Subscribe to our free Newsletter (sample here)

Gold: Weekly Chart

There is a potential for gold to be forming a bottom, based on the explanation provided on the chart below (ironically, “ESF” on the chart refers to the Exchange Stabilization Fund) where you continue to see a series of lower highs and lower lows, but we have yet to see any definition that incorporates that kind of activity to define an up trend.  The current rally in gold has not yet surpassed the mid-October swing high.

GC W 13 Dec 14

Like this article on Facebook

Gold: Daily Chart

In order to say the daily trend is up (which may not necessarily change the higher time frame weekly chart) gold needs to:

  • demonstrate stronger EUM (Ease of Upward Movement), evidenced by:
    1. wider range bars with strong closes and
    2. increased volume (Part 1)
  • and see a market correction that shows a weak reaction in the form of:
    1. smaller ranges,
    2. positive closes, and
    3. decreased volume, indicating selling has dried up (Part 2).

Part 2 is what confirms Part 1 that enables one to say with more authority that a trend change has taken place.

If the Part 2 correction:

  • takes the form of  wide range bars (showing ease of movement),
  • closes on the lower part of the range, and
  • increased volume,


  • a new low can occur,
  • or it is a sign that price has more work to do before turning stronger,

and being long could prove costly.

GC D 13 Dec 14

Follow the munKNEE  on Twitter 

Silver: Weekly Chart

Despite silver’s chart structure being much weaker than gold’s, and it requiring a lot more
effort to change its down trend, silver has been performing slightly better than gold, using
the gold/silver ratio as a gauge.  It is presently just under 72:1 where in recent weeks it
had been consistently running between 73:1 and 75:1. With that observation, nothing much further can be added until the chart structure improves.

SI W 13 Dec 14

The immediate band of resistance from October will provide important feedback by the manner in which silver negotiates it.  A strong rally above 18, followed by a weak correction would go a long way to improve the odds favorably for silver.  Until some more visible sign(s) of strength enters this market, it will continue to meander.

SI D 13 Dec 14

Beyond the chart reads, we remain staunch advocates for buying and holding either or both metals.


The insanity of ongoing central bank  suppression of gold and silver to levels that defy the unprecedented demand world-wide will come to an end, which always comes back to the “When” factor.  When it happens and not a day before, is the best answer we know.

Editor’s Note: The author’s views and conclusions in the above article are unaltered and no personal comments have been included to maintain the integrity of the original post. Furthermore, the views, conclusions and any recommendations offered in this article are not to be construed as an endorsement of such by the editor.

* http://edgetraderplus.com/market-commentaries/gold-and-silver-wall-street-aka-united-states-pulls-off-another-destructive-coup

Post a Comment on this article (Scroll down to bottom of page)

Related Articles:

1. Noonan on Gold & Silver: “Odds favor retesting lower from here”

Every bottom undergoes a process of retesting but none is yet apparent in gold & silver. In the early part of 2014 we said that the second half could likely be more of the same as it was in 2013, and with just a few weeks away from the end of the year, prospects for 2015 can equally be brought into question regarding the price appreciation of gold and silver. Read More »

2. Noonan: Downward Pace of Gold & Silver To Slow – Here’s Why

A look at the charts shows that there is no foreseeable change for gold and silver that has not already been covered in previous articles, and certainly elsewhere, and puts an end to all the pronouncements from so-called experts that PMs would be much higher. Read More »

3. Noonan: Rallies In Gold & Silver Don’t Suggest A Change In Downward Trends – Yet

As encouraging as the recent rallies in gold and silver may seem, they are still just rallies within a clearly defined down trend. For trading purposes, there is no reason to be long. For buying and holding physical gold and silver, there are too many reasons not to be long. Plan accordingly. Read More »

4. Noonan on Gold & Silver: “Don’t Jump the Gun! Let the Market Prove Itself First”

It can take some time for a trend to change course so being first in is not always the best situation. Let me explain further with the use of some enlightening charts on gold and silver. Read More »

5. Noonan On “What the Charts Are Saying About Gold & Silver Today”

Earlier this year we said that 2014 could well be a repeat of 2013 in terms of unrealized expectations for much higher gold & silver price levels and over the ensuing months have continued to advise everyone to stay out of the long side of the paper futures market for as long as the trend continued down. That came from an obvious read of the charts. This article looks at what the gold and silver charts are saying today. Read More »

6. Noonan on Gold & Silver: “No Turnaround Soon; Just Keep Holding & Buying & WAIT!”

…Have gold and silver seen a bottom yet, and is there a turnaround soon in the cards? No, and no…It is still business as usual as gold and silver languish around recent lows.  There is no date one can mark on the calendar that points to an end of the Rothschild dominance over Western fiat currencies and their suppression of … Read More »

7. Noonan on Gold & Silver: “There’s NO Turnaround In Sight!”

Things just took a turn for the worst, and there is no turnaround in sight. Unless and until demand enters the picture, price will continue lower until it finds demand sufficient to effect a change. For right now, there is no demand apparent. What else can be said. This is like watching a car teetering on the edge of the cliff, waiting to see if/when it falls. The trend is down, and that is all you need to know! Read More »

8. Noonan: “Gold & Silver Will Turn When They’re Ready & They’re Far From Ready!” Here’s Why”

Time is running out for all the 2014 enthusiasts that are calling for higher prices in gold and silver by year-end. The lessons learned from 2013 have been forgotten as not only are prices not beginning to move higher, they are making new recent lows. Incredibly enough, many of these prognosticators are paid pretty well by their subscribers. Lesson to be learned? Absolutely no one can divine the future. Stop listening to what others are saying, and pay attention to what the charts are saying – and below is a summary of just that. Read More »

9. Noonan on Gold & Silver: “The Market Is ‘Speaking’ & THIS Is What the Charts Are Saying”

This is one of those times where it is best to focus on pictures of the market, over various time frames, to get a better handle on what to expect moving forward, and a look at the charts tells us in no uncertain terms that the end is not yet in sight. Here is our read of what the market is saying, and has been saying for some time. Read More »

10. Noonan: These Charts Say Trend STILL Bearish For Both Gold & Silver

No one knows when gold and silver will rally and anyone who says otherwise has already been proven wrong. Despite a decent rally in both gold and silver over the past 7 trading days, a look at the charts shows that both remain in bear market conditions overall with no defined indication of ongoing strength. Read More »

11. Noonan: Everything’s Upside Down, Including the Price For Gold & Silver – Here’s Why

We live in an Alice In Wonderland, circa Orwell’s 1984 world. Everything is upside down, and that includes the price for gold and silver. Read More »

12. Noonan: How Long Will These Low Prices In Gold & Silver Continue?

How long these low prices in gold and silver will continue is the ever pressing question on the minds of the gold and silver community and topic of so many articles written by the experts. While many have striven to provide an answer, and 2013 failed to match the “predictions” as to the “When?” issue, the best answer is: For as long as it takes. Here’s why. Read More »

13. Noonan: What’s It Going to Take to Cause a Sharp Price Reversal for Gold & Silver?

There is not a shred of evidence that the price of gold is about to embark upon a much higher trajectory. What the market is saying is that nothing in the news is disturbing the bottoming process. Read More »

14. Noonan: Gold Remains Low For These Compelling Reasons

The current unnatural control over the natural forces of Supply/Demand could continue much longer than most expect – the disappointing expectations for 2013 may repeat in 2014. Here is how we see the developing “story” that explains why gold and silver have not changed trend. Read More »

15. Noonan: Forget About $5,000+ Gold; It Ain’t Goin’ Happen Any Time Soon!

Tell us where in the charts below there are any indications that the “true” value for gold should be in the $5,000 – $10,000 per troy ounce range, or silver in the $100 – $300 range. If you see extraordinary bullish signs within them, let us know, because we certainly keep looking and cannot find any needle in these “haystack” charts! Read More »

16. Noonan: Gold & Silver Will Not Rally-to-the-Sky in 2014 – Here’s Why

No matter what you hear or read about gold and the prospects for substantially higher price levels, the trend is down, exactly opposite of what you know. When you compare what you know, an opinion, with what the market is telling you, the market is a more accurate measure, however counter-intuitive it may be to your opinion, [and THIS is what the markets are saying]. Read More »