Monday , 17 June 2024

World Gold Council Report: A Look Back – A Look Forward

What a year for gold in 2011! It was up 9% in US dollar price terms and even more so in most other currencies; outperformed a large number of asset classes reinforcing its role as a foundation asset in portfolio construction; provided liquidity when investors needed it the most, acting as a risk management vehicle [and] served as a currency hedge throughout the year, in particular against the US dollar;…[and] gold fundamentals of supply and demand were robust [ which should remain so in 2112]. Words: 1530

So says the World Gold Council ( in edited excerpts from the original report*.

Lorimer Wilson, editor of (A site for sore eyes and inquisitive minds) and (Your Key to Making Money!) has edited ([ ]), abridged (…) and reformatted (some sub-titles and bold/italics emphases) the article below for the sake of clarity and brevity to ensure a fast and easy read. The article’s views and conclusions are unaltered and no personal comments have been included to maintain the integrity of the original article. Please note that this paragraph must be included in any article re-posting to avoid copyright infringement.

The report goes on to say, in part:

After a tumultuous year in financial markets around the world, gold was one of few asset classes to deliver positive returns (Chart 1) up 9% in 2011…based on the London PM fix, marking the 11th consecutive year of price increases.

Chart 1: Relative price performace in 2011 for various assets

Chart 1: Relative price performace in 2011 for various assets

Gold’s price appreciation was generally higher in currencies other than the US dollar, especially in developing markets, with the exception of China, as they saw marked declines of their currencies against the US dollar in the latter part of the year (see Table 1 below). Not surprisingly, the euro depreciated the most amongst developed countries relative to the US dollar, on the back of continuing sovereign debt issues, pushing gold prices up 11.6% in local terms during the year. Over the same period, gold also rose in Japanese yen terms, but only by 3.6% as Japan’s currency was one of the few to strengthen against the US dollar.

Table 1: Gold performance in various currencies 1

Table 1: Gold performance in various currencies

True to its role as a vehicle for diversification and risk management, gold outperformed a large majority of assets, including oil, on a risk-adjusted basis during a year of marked uncertainty and increased volatility. However, gold’s performance was not all smooth sailing throughout the year, particularly during the latter months. A cursory look at the events that unfolded during the year helps to identify what factors influenced gold’s performance in 2011 (as per Chart 2 below).

Chart 2: Gold price (US$/oz), London PM fix

Chart 2: Gold price (US$/oz), London PM fix

Between January and August and particularly during the summer, further deterioration of Greek finances and its potential ripple effect on larger EU member countries coupled with the possibility of a technical default by the US on its government debt, helped push gold prices higher…By early August, gold had broken the US$1,800/oz level and reached a record high of US$1,895/oz on the London PM fix on 6 September, having traded as high US$1,921/oz intra-day.

Following the Federal Open Markets Committee (FOMC) meeting of 21 September, the Fed announced its latest stimulus measure which effectively changed the composition of its securities portfolio by extending duration and by marginally changing the type of securities held. Designed to drive down long-term interest rates without increasing the central bank’s balance sheet (or the monetary base), it took many investors by surprise. With hopes of further quantitative easing in the near term diminished, the US dollar promptly rallied – a trend that generally continued for the remainder of the year…

Who in the world is currently reading this article along with you? Click here

In turn, gold prices retreated, falling to the US$1,600/oz level, in part due to a stronger US dollar…[but also] due to being one of the few liquid assets with positive returns which investors could use to cover some of their losses. This can also be seen on Chart 3 [below], in which net-long positions by money managers fell from the highest level in August to an annual multiyear low by December. These positions are typically used as a measure of the more speculative/short-term end of investment demand as they are normally funded by levered positions.

In all, gold’s price pullback of 15% was labelled by some commentators as a break in gold’s multi-year trend. On the contrary, a careful analysis of gold’s historical performance shows that it has experienced various pullbacks over the last 10 years. Gold prices, as with any other freely traded asset, are set by many investors and consumers looking for prices they consider “fair” to transact. This “price discovery”, in turn, naturally moves prices up and down. Our analysis shows that there have only been six previous instances in which the price of gold has fallen by more than 10% over the past decade and once the price has stabilised to a certain (typically new) level, it resumed its upward trajectory. Moreover, the price pullback experienced this past September was less pronounced than the pullback gold experienced during 2008. Even then, gold rose to finish the year with positive returns. Beyond the day-to-day market movements, the underlying gold price trajectory is based on its long-term supply and demand dynamics which remain robust.

Chart 3: COMEX net long non-commercial/non-reportable positions by source as a % of open interest

Chart 3: COMEX net long on non-commercial and non-reportable positions by source as a percentage of open interest

During the fourth quarter, in spite of a stronger US dollar, gold demand remained buoyant due, in part, to recurring concerns on the health of European finances and the regional economy, but also as other important components of the gold market came into play.

Central banks, which have been predominantly net purchasers of gold since Q2 2009, increased their activity during 2011. Central bank net-buying is poised to have a record year, and many of these purchases happened during Q3 and Q4.

Additionally, investment activity remained healthy as market participants continued to access the market whether through bars and coins or other vehicles. In fact, gold-backed ETFs, collectively, added 75 tonnes of gold between September and December alone (out of 153 tonnes during the full year).

Towards the year-end gold prices came under pressure once more, influenced by profit-taking and the rebalancing of portfolios. Additionally, as a higher number of clearing houses, exchanges and banks included gold in the assets accepted as collateral, gold gained in prominence as an integral part of the financial and monetary system. Faced with margin calls on other positions, some investors sold gold to finance these calls, thereby putting further pressure on the price.

Volatility and correlation

Gold’s consistent performance as a diversifier and vehicle to manage risk effectively, along with its more traditional role in capital preservation, are key to its importance in asset allocation as a foundation to a portfolio.

At first glance, it seemed that the swings gold experienced during the second half of the year had a negative effect on its key functions in a portfolio, by adding volatility and increasing correlation. However, a more careful analysis presents a very different picture. Gold’s price volatility increased during August and October; however, gold’s volatility rose less than that of the equity market – illustrated in the S&P 500 volatility – which is what typically occurs during periods of higher uncertainty in financial markets (as seen in Chart 4). As such, while gold prices were not immune to the effects of financial markets swings, its volatility was considerably more stable than that experienced by equities.

Chart 4: Volatility ratio between S&P 500 and gold (US$/oz)*

Chart 4: Volatility ratio between S&P 500 and gold (US$/oz)*

Moreover, many market observers pointed towards an increase in gold’s correlation to equities as a sign of less robust diversification. Our analysis shows that this is not necessarily true and while short-term changes in correlation could be observed, gold’s long-term low correlations to most assets underpin its effectiveness as a portfolio diversifier:

  1. Gold is negatively correlated with the US dollar. In periods in which the US dollar depreciates, gold prices tend to rise. If this relationship was symmetrical, we would expect that as the US dollar appreciates gold prices would fall, but the negative correlation often weakens when the dollar is buoyant, making gold a particularly effective hedge. That said, in the short-term, upward pressure on the US dollar is likely to exert downward pressure on the gold price.
  2. Equity markets were under pressure as well for a myriad of reasons which, in turn, increased the perception of synchronicity between gold and equities. In reality, while gold’s correlation to equities did increase, it did not do so more than in previous periods. During financial markets crises experienced over the past few years, there has been an initial short-term period of “increased” correlation between gold and equities. This is because investors first seek cash (US dollars in this case), as they reduce risk in their portfolios. Subsequently, investors tend to re-balance their holdings and seek gold (and other real assets) to preserve wealth further. These actions tend to reduce gold’s correlation to equities (see Chart 5). As such, this period may not be any different from previous instances and gold may go back to its low long-term correlation to equities.

Chart 5: Correlation* on gold (US$/oz), theS&P 500 and trade-weighted US$

Chart 5: Correlation* on gold (US$/oz), theS&P 500 and the trade-weighted US$


Gold had another positive year:

  • gold ended 2011 9% higher in US dollar price terms and rising even further in most currencies.
  • gold outperformed a large number of asset classes, in spite of an interim increase in volatility which affected all financial markets, reinforcing its role as a foundation asset in portfolio construction.
  • gold provided liquidity when investors needed it the most, acting as a risk management vehicle.
  • gold served as a currency hedge throughout the year, in particular against the US dollar [and] while such an inverse relationship pushed gold prices down toward the end of 2011, in part driven by profit taking and portfolio rebalancing, we believe gold fundamentals of supply and demand (including investment, central bank activity, jewellery and technology consumption) will [remain robust – in 2112].


Why spend time surfing the internet looking for informative and well-written articles on the health of the economies of the U.S., Canada and Europe; the development and implications of the world’s financial crisis and the various investment opportunities that present themselves related to commodities (gold and silver in particular) and the stock market when we do it for you. We assess hundreds of articles every day, identify the best and then post edited excerpts of them to provide you with a fast and easy read.

Sign-up for Automatic Receipt of Articles in your Inbox or via FACEBOOK | and/or TWITTER so as not to miss any of the best financial articles on the internet edited for clarity and brevity to ensure you a fast an easy read.