Friday , 19 July 2024

Following “the 4% Rule” In Retirement Is Mostly Unnecessary – Here’s Why

“…If you’re planning for retirement, it won’t take long before you come across the 4% safe withdrawal rate, which goes something like this: withdraw 4% of your investment portfolio the first year of retirement, and then take that same dollar amount every year, adjusted for inflation…”

Prepared by Lorimer Wilson, editor of – Your KEY To Making Money! [Editor’s Note: This version* of the original article by Chris Reining has been edited ([ ]), restructured and abridged (…) by 53% for a FASTER – and easier – read.]

Here’s how the 4% rule works:

Year 1: Withdraw 4%.

Year 2: Forget you’ve ever heard of the 4% rule and withdraw $40,000 multiplied by the prior years inflation rate. If inflation was 2%, you withdraw $40,800 ($40,000 x 1.02). In year 3, withdraw $40,800 multiplied by the prior years inflation rate, and so on.

The 4% rule only matters for the initial withdrawal, and then it doesn’t matter anymore.

The reason the 4% rule works during recessions is because the 4% rule is based on the worst possible historical scenarios. That’s the whole point.

  • Withdrawing that initial 4% incorporates someone who retires on the cusp of some financial nightmare: the depression, dot-com bubble, recent recession…
  • The withdrawal rules work because that’s how the rules are designed.

In fact, the vast majority of people won’t face sequence of returns risk. They’ll enjoy decent market returns early in retirement [and] their investments will compound…[In fact, according to] Michael Kitces…following the 4% rule is mostly unnecessary. His research shows that

  • if you start retirement with $1 million and use a 4% initial withdrawal, you’re more likely to have $5 million after 30 years than ever dip into principal.

It’s probably okay to use a higher initial withdrawal, but you use the rules because it’s impossible to predict how the future unfolds…

The problem isn’t that planning with these rules doesn’t work. They’ve worked for nearly 50 years. The problem is you can’t predict what will happen. At some point you have to…adapt to the unexpected conditions that life throws at you.”

(*The author’s views and conclusions are unaltered and no personal comments have been included to maintain the integrity of the original article. Furthermore, the views, conclusions and any recommendations offered in this article are not to be construed as an endorsement of such by the editor.)

Related Articles from the munKNEE Vault:

1. Use The 4% Rule To Thrive In Retirement – Here’s How

This post looks at the 4% rule to understand why it works so well in retirement, what could possibly be a stumbling block and how to overcome such a situation should it arise.

2. Don’t Use the 4% and 60-40 Investing Rules of Thumb – They’re Dumb! Here’s Why

One of the things that really frosts me is the financial planning industry that insists on using rules of thumb such as the “set and forget” tools – specifically the 4% and 60-40 rules.

For the latest – and most informative – financial articles sign up (in the top right corner) for your FREE bi-weekly Market Intelligence Report newsletter (see sample here).

Scroll to very bottom of page & add your comments on this article. We want to share what you have to say!

If you enjoyed reading the above article please hit the “Like” button, and if you’d like to be notified of future articles, hit that “Follow” link.

Want your very own financial site? is being GIVEN away – Check it out!

A note from Lorimer Wilson, owner/editor of – Your KEY to Making Money!:
“Illness necessitates that I spend less time on this unique & successful site so:
  1. if you’re interested in exploring the opportunity of taking the site to the next level as associate editor/webmaster
  2. and being rewarded with full ownership – at absolutely no cost to you – at the end of the second year of involvement
  3. please indicate your interest in the Comment section below
  4. and I will get in touch with you.”