Thursday , 25 July 2024

U.S. Is NOT Going to Become Energy Independent – Period! Here are 3 Reasons Why (+2K Views)

The United States is not going to become energy independent because of tight oil.natural-gas Period. Reports to the contrary are an illusion of U.S. energy independence based on unrealistic assumptions and projections about the long-term potential of oil production from tight formations like the Bakken Shale in North Dakota and the Eagle Ford Shale in Texas. There are several compelling reasons for this [as outlined below]. Words: 575

So writes Arthur Berman*, Labyrinth Consulting Services.

This article is presented compliments of (Your Key to Making Money!) and may have been edited ([ ]), abridged (…) and/or reformatted (some sub-titles and bold/italics emphases) for the sake of clarity and brevity to ensure a fast and easy read. Please note that this paragraph must be included in any article re-posting to avoid copyright infringement.

Below are Berman’s 3  reasons why the U.S. is not going to become energy independent because of tight oil:

1. These new plays have extremely high decline rates. 

The aggregate decline rate of producing Bakken and Eagle Ford wells is 38% and 42% per year, respectively.  Conventional oilfield decline rates average 4-5% per year. This means that the only way that production can continue to grow is by constantly drilling new wells.  At roughly $10 million per well, that requires access to vast amounts of capital. Rig counts in these plays are now below the peaks.  This implies that there are either capital or well performance constraints.

I estimate that 1,500 new wells must be drilled in the Bakken ($17 billion) and 800 new wells in the Eagle Ford ($8 billion) this year just to keep production from declining.  Almost 70% of Bakken and almost 90% of Eagle Ford production in the first half o 2012 is form wells that began production in the last 18 months.

2. These tight oil plays require $80-90 per barrel oil prices to break even. 

None of the exuberant reports about U.S. energy independence discuss cost, price or profit margins — they only focus on volumes.  The truth is that oil prices have been in the $87-$95 range for the last quarter which means that profits are marginal in these plays.  In fields or “sweet spots” operators are making money but the average well in the play loses money.

 3. The biggest and most productive discoveries are made early and, for the most part, subsequent discoveries are smaller and well performance is poorer.

Predictions that the U.S. will surpass Saudi Arabia and Russia in oil production must assume that current discovery and production rates in the Bakken and Eagle Ford will continue, except that they never do. The fallacy of this assumption is noted in a January 15, 2013 report by Bernstein Research: “Analysis of well results in the Eagle Ford (horizontal), Bakken (horizontal), and Permian (both vertical and horizontal)suggest average per-well oil IP [initial production] rates have peaked and are currently below 2010-11 highs.”


The United States consumes approximately 15 million barrels of crude oil per day and produces about 6.5 million barrels per day including the Bakken and Eagle Ford additions to date.  That means that 8.5 million barrels per day must be imported.

The U.S. Energy Information Administration (Department of Energy) estimates that U.S. crude oil production will increase to nearly eight million barrels per day by 2020 and then decline.  If the EIA is correct, the United States will still have to import about seven million barrels per day allowing for demand decline, and that does not look like energy independence to me.

Editor’s Note: The author’s views and conclusions are unaltered and no personal comments have been included to maintain the integrity of the original article. Furthermore, the views, conclusions and any recommendations offered in this article are not to be construed as an endorsement of such by the editor.

*About Arthur Berman (  Mr. Berman is a petroleum geologist with 34 years of oil & gas industry experience – 20 years working with Amoco (now BP) and 14 years as a consulting geologist – a Director of The Association for the Study of Peak Oil, and a past Director of The Houston Geological Society and The Society of Independent Professional Earth Scientists.)

Related Articles:

1. Is the Abundance of Natural Gas the Answer to America’s Energy Needs?


The shale revolution has come as a surprise to many, but natural gas is now so plentiful and cheap that it could be an energy game changer. This infographic explores natural gas, its properties, natural gas market dynamics, supply forecasts, demand, the shale revolution, and the switch from coal to natural gas.

2. Shale Gas Info: What is Shale? What is Fracking? What Does Its Future Mean For America?

Natural gas has the potential to bridge the gap between the current oil dominated energy mix and sustainable renewables. It’s cheap, abundant, and the cleanest fossil fuel in the world. In fact, at today’s consumption rates, estimated US natural gas resources could be used to supply domestic electricity generation for 52 years.That being said, shale gas is trapped thousands of feet underground. How do we extract it and what does the process look like? The infographic below has all the details.

3. Here’s the Complete Picture Regarding Natural Gas

New gas technology such as hydraulic fracturing (fracking) and horizontal drilling have changed the complexion of natural gas in North America. This infographic explores natural gas, its properties, natural gas market dynamics, supply forecasts, demand, the shale revolution, and the switch from coal to natural gas. We also raise questions about methane leakage and hydraulic fracturing.

4. Fracking: Everything You’ve Always Wanted to Know but Were Embarrassed to Ask

Marathon Oil has a great animation on the basics of hydraulic fracturing or “fracking.” It explains how horizontal drilling works and explains the roles of water and sand. Take a look.

5. U.S. Has 3rd Largest Natural Gas Field in the World – Which Other Countries are Included in the Top 10?

Natural gas is increasingly becoming an important fuel in meeting the global energy needs. Let’s take a quick look at the largest natural gas fields in the world. Words: 300

Other “Economic Straight Talk” Commentary:

1. “Ponzi Finance”: What Must Happen To Bring It To An End?

The Boston Consulting Group has issued a paper that recommends 10 steps that developed countries must take to end what they refer to as ‘Ponzi finance’ and to return to a sustainable growth path but I believe their recommendations to be but theoretical and impractical constructs. While I believe we face – and will experience – interesting, speculative, fragile, and very challenging and very likely life-changing times going forward, I believe that the only thing that will force developed country politicians to work for common purposes is a further global financial crisis. This article provides an overview and assessment of said paper and the rationale for my position. Words: 600

2. Don’t Blithely Accept the Views of Stock & Commodity Commentators – Here’s Why

Many…commentaries by people referred to as ‘gurus’ or ‘experts’…often don’t state the assumptions that underlie the opinions they express leaving the reader…to take at face value what is said based on ‘assumed expertise’. I suggest you exercise caution and not blithely accept the views of  ‘experts’ without first understanding their underlying assumptions and then satisfying yourself that those assumptions both make sense and are internally consistent with the views and opinions the ‘experts’ express, and the advice they give. Let me explain more fully below.

3. It’s Crucial to Challenge ‘Commentator Credibility’ When Evaluating Gold ‘Mining’ Companies – Here’s Why


Every day now there is Media and Internet commentary on the current prices at which gold mining stocks are trading. Some of this commentary is excellent, some seems to be written from a “vested interest’ perspective and some is very simplistic. [This article discusses unstated underlying assumptions that some commentators base their views on, endeavours to provide a greater understanding of the gold ‘mining’ sector and influences on pricing of sector stocks and what investors need to do before investing in said sector.] Words: 2030

4. Campbell’s Challenge: Stop Being a Lemming! Contradictory Points of View are Imperative – Here’s Why


It is all too easy to look for like-minded persons who continuously reinforce one’s own views – a clear form of ‘lemmingism’, to coin a new word. Instead, one should make an effort to recognize both reader and writer biases when reading and thinking about things found on the Internet in social media websites and blogs. [Let me explain my views on that further.] Words: 720

5. Campbell: Balanced Opinions Regarding Gold & Silver are Paramount – Here’s Why


If you hold, or are considering holding, physical gold or silver or both, [it is imperative that you] read as many ‘balanced opinions’ as you possibly can with respect to ownership of each. [Here’s why]. Words: 337



One comment

  1. The biggest reason is that Big Oil is doing everything it can (along with Big Nuclear) to slow down and/or stop any additional conversion to Solar, despite what they are telling ratepayers… They see conversion as a loss of market share and they are paying their Political Officials plenty to see things their way or else!